Tottenham’s Igor Tudor sack decision ahead of Liverpool clash sums things up

OPINION: Tottenham have to be strong and make a bold decision about Igor Tudor ahead of Sunday’s trip to face Liverpool at Anfield

There is a haunting brand of dread currently hanging over the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium. Any lingering, ironised hope that this was all just a long, painful blip has been suffocated by the hushed, airless sound of a multi-billion-pound sporting institution being slowly fed into an industrial shredder.

When Thomas Frank was ushered out the door last month, Spurs fans were promised a steady hand, a fresh perspective, an injection of life. Instead, they got Igor Tudor: a man who looks less like a master tactician and more like a confused tourist who has accidentally wandered onto the touchline while looking for the British Museum.

Four games, four defeats, 14 goals conceded. That makes for more dismal reading than The Da Vinci Code.

The 4-1 mauling at the hands of Arsenal was bad enough, not least since Tottenham played the second half with all the defensive resistance of a damp digestive biscuit. But the 5-2 capitulation against Atletico Madrid in the Champions League on Tuesday night signalled the moment the ‘interim’ needed to become the ‘outerim’.

JOIN US ON FACEBOOK! Latest news, analysis and much more on Mirror Football’s Facebook page

READ MORE: Sean Dyche emerges as shock candidate for next Tottenham boss if Spurs sack Igor TudorREAD MORE: Tottenham star Antonin Kinsky breaks silence after Champions League ‘nightmare’

To find yourself 4-0 down after 22 minutes is a feat of footballing incompetence that even 2007/08 Derby County would cringe at. Sure, they responded well to going 4-0 down, but that’s like the Black Knight from Monty Python and the Holy Grail responding well to having his arms cut off. ‘Tis but a scratch.

And then there’s the Antonin Kinsky situation. Dropping Guglielmo Vicario for such a high-stakes European clash in favour of a Loris Karius-cosplaying backup who looked like he’d won his gloves in a raffle was the sort of unnecessarily bonkers decision that’s more difficult to defend than Joey Barton’s arrest record.

Granted, hindsight is 20/20. But since goalkeeping mistakes – unlike mistakes higher up the pitch – are completely ruinous, Kinsky’s inclusion was simply unjustifiable. His performance was a masterclass in gravitational uncertainty. Every kick, every step, every flap of the arm felt like watching a newborn gazelle stumble its way past a clan of salivating hyenas.

Slippery pitch or not, his agitated, spasmodic inexperience cost Spurs two goals, the tie, and the one remaining molecule of pride in the building. Putting him in the starting XI was a selection that exists beyond the realm of tactical error and firmly in the territory of gross negligence.

Speaking of hare-brained selections, Tottenham’s decision to hire a manager with zero Premier League experience and no track record of navigating a relegation dogfight – save for a four-game stint in charge of Udinese back in 2018 or something – was an act of pure self-sabotage.

In the technical area, Tudor cuts a chilly, monolithic figure – a slab of Croatian granite that seems entirely disconnected from the flesh-and-blood humans wearing white shirts in front of him.

Watching Djed Spence having to physically chase his manager down to get a simple acknowledgement after being subbed off against Atletico was a damning indictment of the atmosphere. Tudor didn’t just ignore him; he seemed to treat Spence’s presence as a minor atmospheric disturbance, a leaf blowing past a statue.

There’s just such an air of inevitable failure radiating from Tudor. He’s the dark matter of management, a dense, unobservable force that somehow makes everything around it move more slowly, feel heavier and look infinitely more miserable. He stands there, brooding and inscrutable, while the house burns down, seemingly convinced that if he stares at the pitch hard enough, good things will happen.

Meanwhile, in the real world, the walls are closing in. Nottingham Forest and West Ham are quietly picking up points – turning the most unlikely relegation story since Manchester United went down in 1974 into a grim, near-tangible reality.

With Liverpool looming this weekend and the return leg against Atletico to follow, Spurs are staring down the barrel of eight straight defeats. Imagine the confidence in that dressing room heading into the relegation six-pointer against Forest on March 22. By then, it’ll be as non-existent as the cartilage in Ledley King’s left knee.

Tottenham need to face the cold, hard facts. The Tudor dynasty has already collapsed, and waiting for a turnaround could cost them their Premier League status. The board needs to cut their losses. Now.

Tudor hasn’t improved the tactics, hasn’t improved the shape, hasn’t mended the defence and has spectacularly failed to improve the vibes. At this point, the quality of the opposition he’s faced is a moot point. Context doesn’t buy you safety. All that matters is points, and Spurs are currently about as likely to earn any as they are to convince Harry Kane to re-sign for them in the Championship.

Sometimes, strong leadership isn’t about ‘staying the course’ – it’s about admitting you’ve steered the ship into a lighthouse. Tudor himself provided the blueprint for his own exit; he hooked Kinsky for Vicario after 18 farcical minutes at the Metropolitano, and the improvement was immediate. Spurs must now give Tudor the Kinsky treatment.

Who comes in to replace him? Frankly, it almost doesn’t matter. Tudor has become a form of performance poison. The clock is ticking, the sirens are blaring, and the missile hatches are opening. Tottenham may only have days to save themselves.

Sack him now, or prepare for Tuesday nights in Preston.

Sky Sports discounted Premier League and EFL package

This article contains affiliate links, we will receive a commission on any sales we generate from it. Learn more

£43

£35

Sky

Get the deal here

Sky has slashed the price of its Essential TV and Sky Sports bundle ahead of the 2025/26 season, saving members £192 and offering more than 1,400 live matches across the Premier League, EFL and more.

Sky will show at least 215 live Premier League games next season, an increase of up to 100 more.