Manchester City 0-4 Tottenham: Premier League – as it happened

Jamie Jackson was at the Etihad, and here’s his report. Thanks for reading this MBM. Nighty night, keep safe and warm in the storm.

Ange Postecoglou speaks to Sky. “It’s significant in terms of who you’re playing against … I’m proud of the lads … resilience and discipline … City test every aspect of your game and we handled it really well … we knew they’d come out pretty hot … they’re a pretty proud club … I thought we’re going to weather a storm … we grew into the game … played some good football … scored some great goals … defended as we needed to … James Maddison was outstanding … great … he’s gone through a bit of a lean spell but I’ve never doubted his ability … when Kulusevski plays wide against City he always causes them problems … I thought it’d work well … I take it personally if players aren’t playing to their levels and Madders hasn’t reached his levels and that’s on me to get him back up there … we’ve done a lot of work … I felt he was ready to go … it was an important game for us … the way the boys reacted … we stuck together and it reflected in a great performance today … I think we’re on the right track … we have to make sure our levels don’t drop … enjoy it, it doesn’t come along too often.”

Pep Guardiola speaks to Sky Sports. “We started really well … chances … the first time they arrived we conceded … then it was a little bit more difficult … chances were there … we cannot handle the duels like we normally are able to … it cannot happen … when you play teams in the Premier League you can concede chances … when you are in the situation we are in, it is tougher … always in life it can happen … we have to congratulate Tottenham then look at ourselves … there a few reasons why we are not able to be consistent … the balance is not in the right moment … of course Rodri is important … there are a lot of little things … when it is going bad you have to come back with the process … we have to refresh our minds … the season is so long … many things will happen … the situation is new for us … you have to accept it and move forward.”

For the record, Spurs won that match on the xG as well. But not quite so convincingly. Final score: City 2.15, Spurs 2.51.

Birthday boy and player of the match James Maddison, 28 today, talks to Sky. “These are rare days … to come to the champions … especially City … to come and win 4-0 is special … these are the days you remember … it’s important we enjoy it … 28 sounds quite old to me now! … when you make the sacrifice of missing a birthday, they’re the moments that make it all worth it.”

He’s then asked by Jamie Redknapp whether his first goal was a bit of a shinner. “On my birthday, Jamie, really?!” Full bellows of laughter in the Sky studio for that comeback.

This is the first time the champions of England have lost five games in a row, in all competitions, since 1956. The defending champs that season were Chelsea, and that run included a 4-0 defeat by Tottenham Hotspur. Manchester City will desperately hope that’ll be the only coincidence between the two fiascos, because Chelsea ‘56 went on to extend their miserable sequence with two draws and another two defeats. Next up for City: Feyenoord (h), Liverpool (a), Nottingham Forest (h), Crystal Palace (a).

Post-match postbag. “When you get the fixture list at the beginning of the season, fans of all teams have to be thinking Ipswich at home is your most likely win; City away your most likely defeat. Ladies and gentlemen, I give you Tottenham Hotspur” – Tom Atkins

“Bernardo Silva’s reaction to getting a fully justified yellow card also scored a 10 on the Toddler’s Logic Simulator. Full-on turned-back mode. If I don’t see the ref waving the shiny yellow at me, it didn’t happen. Waaaaah!” – Paul McGrory

“Señor Porro refusing to celebrate against a team he never played a game for is a bit of a reach, no?” – Matthew Lysaght

“Ladies and gentlemen, the irony is the Spurs manager is still more likely to be sacked at the end of the season. Funny old game, innit?” – Philip Ritson

That result has huge significance for both teams. Tottenham, who were in the bottom half at start of play, are now sixth in the table, right back in the mix. Manchester City meanwhile remain five points behind the leaders Liverpool, who travel to Southampton tomorrow. Should Arne Slot’s team win at St Mary’s, they’ll be eight points clear, and the pressure will be on Pep Guardiola’s side to get something from Anfield next weekend.

That is a performance for the ages by Tottenham Hotspur. They’ve been utterly majestic in every single facet of their game. So much so that it’s easy to forget that Manchester City threatened to play them off the park during the opening exchanges. But Spurs held firm, then uncoiled themselves as an attacking force, and City simply couldn’t cope. James Maddison and Dejan Kulusevski were outrageously good; Son Heung-min not far behind them in that respect either. City hadn’t lost at the Etihad for 52 matches. But now look! The four-in-a-row champions have lost five on the bounce in all competitions. This is an unprecedented slump for City in their modern guise; Pep has never suffered such a humiliating run in his entire managerial career. But take nothing away from how good Tottenham were. What a way to get their season back on track.

FULL TIME: Manchester City 0-4 Tottenham Hotspur

GOAL! Manchester City 0-4 Tottenham Hotspur (Johnson 90+3)

90 min +2: Akanji is booked for a cynical tug on Bergvall.

90 min +1: De Bruyne crosses from the right. Haaland prepares to force home, but Dragusin gets in the road, and nothing comes of the resulting corner. Dragusin celebrated that intervention as he would a goal. City might not have been at their best, but Spurs have defended heroically this evening.

90 min: There will be four additional minutes.

89 min: Happy 28th birthday to James Maddison, who already has two goals to his name, and is now announced as player of the match by Gary Neville on Sky. His work done, he leaves the pitch, along with Sarr and Udogie. They’re all replaced by Bergvall, Werner and Spence.

88 min: Kulusevski spins Foden and makes off down the left. He feeds Johnson on the overlap. Johnson rounds Ederson and, from a tight angle, smacks a shot off the bottom of the left-hand post. The offside flag pops up, Kulusevski having taken far too long to make the pass.

87 min: Foden wins a corner down the right. He wants to take it quickly, but can’t do it, because Udogie, having been flicked, takes the opportunity to go down in the box. The City fans are not impressed, but can’t be bothered to keep up the booing for long. They know this is over.

85 min: De Bruyne has made a difference since coming on, as we always knew he would. He pings a ball down the inside-left channel for Gvardiol, who spins into the box and shoots. It’s no good, and the flag goes up for offside anyway.

84 min: Akanji has a dig that is deflected out for a corner. From the set piece, De Bruyne has a whack. Blocked. City come again, Grealish crossing from the left, Silva blazing a volley well over the bar. Despite it all, the hosts haven’t given up hope here.

82 min: Vicario has made some fine stops tonight. Those two in quick succession, from Gundogan and De Bruyne, have really frustrated City as they look for a goal that would jangle a few Spurs nerves.

80 min: De Bruyne slips Haaland into the box down the right. Haaland opens his body and shoots hard. Vicario parries again. De Bruyne tries to meet the rebound, but succeeds in only kicking Sarr. All of which leads to a rare old brouhaha, and both De Bruyne and Sarr are booked for squaring up to each other. City now getting ragged in mind as well as play.

78 min: Silva is booked for a pretty agricultural swipe at Maddison from behind. His subsequent complaint to the referee registers a full 10 on our Chutzpah-o-meter™.

77 min: De Bruyne slips a clever pass down the right channel to release Gundogan, who shoots hard from a tight angle. Vicario stands tall to block with his chest, and nothing comes of the resulting corner.

75 min: A cute shimmy by Silva down the right. He looks for Haaland in the middle, but Porro is on hand to clear. Silva’s skill at least gets the home crowd excited again … but then Walker blooters a dismal cross out for a goal kick, and the feelgood moment, such as it was, disappears into the ether.

74 min: Here come the cavalry? De Bruyne and Grealish replace Savinho and Lewis.

73 min: Foden wriggles down the inside-left channel and gets a shot away. A pea-roller. It’s easy for Vicario, but it does go down as City’s first strike on target in this second half.

72 min: Walker earns a corner down the right. Foden loops it in. Vicario claims without fuss.

71 min: City pass and probe, probe and pass. Spurs hold their shape. The clock ticks on.

69 min: Gvardiol, who has been decent in attack if nothing else, wedges a cross into the Spurs box from the left. Haaland heads over.

67 min: To be fair to both Kulusevski and Ederson, the keeper still had work to do there, clawing the shot away with a strong hand.

66 min: Solanke barges his way down the middle and suddenly Spurs are three on two. Solanke has options either side, but instead of looking for Maddison to his left, goes for Kulusevski to his right. Kulusevski enters the box but takes too long over the shot, which is eventually slapped straight at Ederson. That – and this is quite the thing to be saying about a team playing Manchester City away – should have been four.

64 min: Savinho floats a diagonal cross towards Gvardiol, just inside the Spurs box on the left. Gvardiol slashes an effort of zero threat over the bar. That’s City’s 14th shot so far this evening; they’ve only managed two on target so far.

63 min: Spurs make their first change, replacing Son with Johnson, who will be used to piling forward in the unfettered style after his international sojourn with Craig Bellamy’s freewheeling Wales.

61 min: Silva worms his way down the right and crosses for Gvardiol, who drives towards the bottom left. Porro blocks and clears, and celebrates as though he’s just scored. Which, in fairness, he also has.

60 min: City go back to what they know best – patient probing – and Ake wins a corner down the left. Spurs deal with it easily enough, Davies heading clear. But suddenly City spring awake, returning the ball into the mixer. Haaland nicks it off Davies on the right-hand edge of the six-yard box, spins, and lashes a shot across Vicario and off the top of the crossbar. So unlucky!

59 min: The rain is coming down in stair-rods now. Even by Mancunian standards, this is quite the downpour. To the great credit of City’s fans, they respond to this miserable state of affairs with an extremely loud rendition of Blue Moon. “Trump heading back to the White House, doomsday fish washing up on the beaches, and City heading to a fifth straight loss? Is this the end of days?” wonders Liz (not the actress) White.

57 min: On Sky, co-commentator Gary Neville suggests that City are being outplayed in every single department. Pep is copping it in the stadium, too. “You’re getting sacked in the morning,” trill the satirists in the Spurs end.

55 min: Lewis skittles Maddison in the frustrated fashion, and goes into the book. The Spurs fans are making one heck of a racket. Can you blame them?

54 min: Spurs are enjoying playing in Manchester this season, aren’t they?

GOAL! Manchester City 0-3 Tottenham Hotspur (Porro 53)

51 min: Pep Guardiola sits on the bench looking downcast, rubbing his head pensively.

49 min: According to Sky, because I’ve certainly not had the time to do the counting, City are currently 52 matches unbeaten at the Etihad. A lot resting on this second half.

47 min: A strangulated chorus of “We’re not really here”. It’s a City song, but you wouldn’t blame Spurs fans for co-opting it right now. “Could you ask the non-golfer David Howell if he is the chess grandmaster David Howell?” asks David (not Howell) Gardner.

Manchester City get the second half started. They’ve replaced John Stones, whose return from injury has lasted just one half of football, with Nathan Aké.

Half-time letters (all, in a very strange coincidence, from readers with famous namesakes). “How in the world is James Maddison 28? He’s had the ‘promising youngster’ tag for absolutely ages. Is he still promising or has he reached his peak?” – Andy (not the cricketer) Flintoff

“City is not balanced on the wing, that is why they are being over run. Doku needs to be in to peg back their wing backs. Gundogan needs to be switched out and Nunes in, he has more dynamic power going forward, he is closer to Rodri than Gundo at the moment. Also I would give Haaland a rest. He misses too many easy chances. Let him marinate and come back hungry” – Kirk (not the actor) Douglas

“This title race really does look like 2019-20 all over again, Which is a terrifying thought, not because I’m not a Liverpool fan, but because parallels to five years ago makes articles like this one even scarier” – David (not the golfer) Howell

“I know what’s really going on here. City’s highly-paid advisors have out-thought the leaden-footed conventional-bound Premier League. If City are convicted of those 115 charges, a punishment of relegation would be moot if they are already demoted, so they will fail to win another game this season, as a kind of situationist jazz happening. City are playing 3-D Chess yet again. Everything connects, Scott. Everything. Connects” – Paul (not the guy who played piano on Bob Dylan’s classic mid-60s trilogy Bringing It All Back Home, Highway 61 Revisited and Blonde on Blonde) Griffin

Some much-needed succour for the champions here. Since the start of last season, according to a graphic flashed up by Sky Sports, no team has recovered more points from losing positions than Manchester City. That probably doesn’t come as a huge surprise, but there it is nonetheless.

37: Manchester City
34: Tottenham Hotspur
32: Liverpool
29: Aston Villa

HALF TIME: Manchester City 0-2 Tottenham Hotspur

45 min +2: City are getting frustrated. Walker upends Maddison down the left and then, a free kick conceded, considers slamming the ball into the ground. He thinks twice, just in time.

45 min: … Akanji harmlessly heads behind. There will be three additional first-half minutes.

44 min: Gvardiol nearly beats Dragusin in a footrace down the left. Not quite, but his presence is enough to win a corner. From which …

43 min: Son has the chance to shoot from just inside the box, but over-thinks things and another chance is gone. City go up the other end, Silva advancing down the left and crossing, Foden scissoring a fine effort over the bar from 12 yards.

42 min: Silva gives the ball away. City have been so careless in possession … which is a very strange thing to be able to type. Kulusevski tees up Bissouma, who lashes a wild effort high over the bar.

41 min: Vicario is back up and ready to go.

39 min: Vicario goes down again, holding his ankle. On comes the physio.

37 min: Porro deals with a long ball down the middle by heading backwards towards his keeper. Not quite enough power. Savinho nearly nips in, but Vicario claims on the edge of the box, before being clattered by the City attacker. A free kick, nothing more. Savinho was entitled to challenge for that loose ball.

36 min: Savinho sends a drive towards the bottom left from distance. Easy enough for Vicario.

35 min: City probe patiently again. But to no avail. Kulusevski attempts a counter down the left before running the ball out of play. He doesn’t give it back immediately to Silva, who rather petulantly nibbles at his ankles. A fussier referee might have booked both players, but this one merely waves play on dismissively. “It looks like Pep is playing midfield wannabes in midfield as well,” quips Yash Gupta.

33 min: The harum-scarum pace and shape of this game is suiting Spurs. City decide to take things down a notch or two with some sterile domination. The patient probing leads to a free kick out on the right, near the corner flag. Foden sails the set piece over everyone’s head in the middle. Goal kick. But that’s better from City, who it’s now easy to forget, looked totally on it during the first ten minutes or so. Now, not so much.

31 min: Gvardiol crosses from the left. Savinho connects with a flying header, the ball heading towards the top-left corner. Vicario turns it around the post, then the flag goes up correctly for offside. Savinho – and Haaland – were both miles off. Neither had reason to be.